In partnership with
Advertise to 40,692 E-Commerce Businesses
Promote your tool, service or upcoming event - Reach Founders
Good morning,
Last Crumb’s limited cookie drops sold out in seconds. The team still changed how it sold its core box.
That is the question at the heart of today’s deep dive: when a successful idea starts limiting the business, do you protect the idea or change it? First, the platform updates worth your attention.
Today: We unpack why Last Crumb changed a model that worked, cover new Meta and Shopify settings, build a better welcome kit and fix one avoidable return reason.
While You Were Building
In the Headlines
Meta opens Customer Lifecycle Strategy to all advertisers
Acquisition campaigns can now receive recommendations to exclude existing customers. Before using it, check how Meta identifies your current buyers; the setting is only as useful as that customer data. CTC’s breakdown goes deeper.
Shopify will calculate tax on return shipping fees
From October 23, this applies to US-address orders for merchants using Shopify Tax or Tax Platform. If you already handle that tax with a manual workaround, review it before the change to avoid counting it twice.
Shopify is showing sale prices to AI shopping agents
Shopify Catalog now shares compare-at prices, allowing shopping agents to recognize a markdown. Check that your compare-at prices are accurate, then review the new visibility toggle in your admin.
Google expands Conversion Lift studies to Search and Performance Max
Eligible advertisers can test how many sales their ads actually caused, rather than relying only on attributed conversions. It is not available to every account: Google lists a minimum of 1,000 observed conversions and a $5,000 study budget.
Worth Knowing
How to find ChatGPT traffic in GA4
Filter Session source / medium for “gpt,” then inspect the landing pages those visitors reach. Treat the result as a partial view: some ChatGPT visits can appear as Direct or Unassigned.
On Socials
1/ A Weekly System for Testing Meta Ads
The useful lesson is to decide when and how you’ll judge a test before launching it. His exact impression and frequency thresholds may not fit your account, but leaving winners alone and giving new ads a defined evaluation window is a discipline worth copying.
2/ More Ads Won’t Fix a Tired Angle
Twenty new hooks can still deliver the same reason to buy to the same audience. If changing the hook doesn’t revive a winner, test a different customer problem or motivation before producing another batch of variations.
Today’s Deep Dive
How Last Crumb Moved Beyond the Idea That Made It Famous
The hardest idea to change is often the one that worked.
It gave your brand its first customers. Your team knows how to run it. People may even associate your brand with it. So when the business starts needing something different, changing course can feel like throwing away your success.
Last Crumb faced exactly that decision.
The idea worked brilliantly
Last Crumb released a limited number of cookie boxes each week. The drops sold out in seconds, and customers posted receipts to show they had secured a box. Founder Derek Jaeger says that in one early drop, more than 1,000 orders were left in carts because the team couldn’t fulfill them. Founder interview
An earlier site capture shows how customers had to wait for the next opportunity to buy. Image source
Then success raised a harder question
The sellouts made the brand famous. They also made it easy to keep measuring success by how quickly each drop disappeared.
Jaeger says the team needed to know whether Last Crumb could become a lasting business without scarcity doing so much of the selling. In 2023, they made the core collection available to buy outside the weekly drops. That also gave them a path to serve more customers and explore retail. Founder interview
The later buying experience: customers could choose the core box and add it to cart. Image source · Current product page
The business had grown beyond its original format
Jaeger now says roughly 60–70% of boxes are bought as gifts. Last Crumb also has a corporate-gifting service. Those customers have their own occasions and deadlines. Making the core box available when they need it serves that business in a way a weekly drop cannot. Founder interview
The same product, now serving a much bigger gifting occasion. Image source
What to copy
Identify the idea your team treats as untouchable because it has worked so well.
Ask whether you would choose the same approach today, knowing who your customers are and how they buy.
If the answer is no, change it before the old success becomes a limit on the next stage.
Your job is to protect the business, not the idea that first made it famous.
Presented by Roku Ads Manager
Blu Dot surpasses 2,000% ROAS with self-serve CTV ads
Home furniture brand Blu Dot blew up on CTV with help from Roku Ads Manager. Here’s how:
After a test campaign reached 211,000 households and achieved 1,010% ROAS, the brand went all in to promote its annual sales event. It removed age and income constraints to expand reach and shifted budget to custom audiences and retargeting, where intent was strongest.
The results speak for themselves. As Blu Dot increased their investment by 10x, ROAS jumped to 2,308% and more page-view conversions surpassed 50,000.
“For CTV campaigns, Roku has been a top performer,” said Claire Folkestad, Paid Media Strategist, Blu Dot. “Comping to our other platforms, we have seen really strong ROAS… and highly efficient CPMs, lower than any other CTV partner we've worked with.”
Using Roku Ads Manager, the campaign moved from a pilot to a permanent performance engine for the brand.
The How-To
How to Build a Welcome Kit Customers Actually Value
A good welcome kit makes the main product easier to use and the first purchase feel like a great deal. Here is how to build one without filling a box with random freebies.
Step 1: Map the first-use experience
Write down what the customer will do when the product arrives. What would help them prepare it, use it or take it with them? RYZE’s starter kit pairs mushroom coffee with creamer, a tumbler and a scoop. The gifts belong to the coffee routine.
RYZE shows the coffee and the gifts as one complete ritual. See the offer.
Step 2: Choose gifts with a job
Oats Overnight includes a shaker to prepare its oats. IM8 includes a bottle, mixer and bonus sachets with its 90-day subscription. Ask of each gift: Would someone buying the main product be excited to receive this? If not, it is probably filler.
Step 3: Create a gap between cost and perceived value
Your cost is not the customer’s value. A kit might cost your brand $50 to provide but feel worth $150 when the items are desirable, work together and create a complete experience. That feeling will not come from adding more cheap extras.
IM8 makes its value easy to see: it shows the three welcome gifts, names each one and itemizes its stated $80 value. If you quote a dollar value, make sure you can support it with genuine prices.
IM8 puts the welcome kit next to the product and shows the value of each gift. See the offer.
Step 4: Deliver what you showed
Check that every gift is in stock and arrives with the first order. For subscriptions, make clear which items are one-time welcome gifts.
Do not build a bigger pile of freebies. Build a better first experience.
🔎 Today’s Growth Rep: Fix one avoidable return reason
Pull your last 30 days of returns and find the product with the most returns.
Why this works:
A return can reveal a promise your product page failed to explain.
Fixing that expectation may help both the buyer and your margin.
Your rep:
Read the return reasons and customer comments for that product.
Find the most common issue you can clarify before purchase, such as fit, size, setup, or what is included.
Update one prominent part of its product page with the missing detail.
Note today’s return rate so you can check whether it changes.
Report: “One return reason addressed.”
Don’t make the return policy do a product page’s job.
Presented by HubSpot
100+ ChatGPT Prompts to Revolutionize Your Day
Supercharge your productivity with HubSpot's comprehensive guide to Chat GPT. This free resource is your fast track to AI mastery:
Industry-Specific Use Cases: 15+ real-world applications across various sectors
Productivity Guide: 21 best practices to 10x your efficiency with AI
Prompt Powerhouse: 100+ ready-to-use prompts for immediate implementation
Challenge Buster: Overcome common AI hurdles with expert strategies
Plus, in-depth sections on email composition, content creation, customer support, and data analysis.